Research Paper

Douglas Haig Butcher Or Hero Essay

Douglas Haig – butcher or hero? By Rupert Colley Douglas Haig – butcher or hero? By Rupert Colley
Feb 5, 2013 ... Douglas Haig, Britain's First World War commander-in-chief from December 1915 to the end of the war, is remembered as the archetypal ...

Douglas Haig Butcher Or Hero Essay

But is the blame justified? The offensive on the somme was initially conceived as part of a wider strategy to wear down the german army by attacking it on all fronts in 1916. It is well-known that, by the end of the first day of fighting on the somme, few objectives had been secured while 19,000 british soldiers were dead. The length of the front meant commanders needed to be a further away to get a complete picture of what was happening.

Many of the shells fired during the week-long preparatory bombardment were duds. He would have preferred to launch an attack in flanders, where the terrain was better and the objectives of greater strategic value. Yet the very nature of warfare during 1914-1918 meant that offense was no match against deeply entrenched defence the weapons of defence during the first world war were much superior to the weapons of offense.

He got his way and the introduction of 32 tanks met with mixed results many broke down but a few managed to penetrate german lines. David lloyd george, prime minister of a coalition government from december 1916, had questioned the point of launching another costly offensive at passchendaele but haig had got the backing of the conservatives within the coalition and so got his way. Haig maintained that the battle achieved the goal of eroding the german army and its will to fight.

They died suffering from the beastly attitudes of the public towards our father. It was lloyd george, who during the election campaign of 1918, had promised a land fit for heroes to live in. Asked by kitcheners superiors in london to report back in confidence on his commander, haig did so with relish, taking delight in criticising the unsuspecting kitchener.

The question remains however would the extra six weeks to prepare made a difference? The answer is probably not. In 1937, a statue of earl haig, the earl haig memorial, was unveiled on londons whitehall (click on the picture to enlarge). In 1914, britain went to war with a small professional army.

Douglas haig, britains first world war commander-in-chief from december 1915 to the end of the war, is remembered as the archetypal donkey leading lions to their death by the thousands. By october, poor weather and continuous artillery bombardment had created a hellish environment for both the allies and the germans. Haigs actions at the battle of mons and the first battle of ypres earned him praise while, conversely, john frenchs fortunes plummeted as the british failed to make any headway on the western front. You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in this website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. But it saddens me my three sisters have not survived to see it.


General Douglas Haig Butcher or Hero? - GCSE History - Marked by ...


However after examining the battle in more detail, some people decided that he was a brilliant general who miscalculated, “a hero of the war”. So was Haig a ...

Douglas Haig Butcher Or Hero Essay

Douglas Haig - Butcher Or Hero? - GCSE History - Marked by ...
Since this has been prepared for a website, it does not take the form of a structured essay, but still provides an interesting and well supported view on Haig's role ...
Douglas Haig Butcher Or Hero Essay Despite having a personal rapport with the king, george v, haig never enjoyed the confidence of lloyd george, Of those that did explode. The question remains however would the extra six weeks to prepare made a difference? The answer is probably not. At the outbreak of the first world war, in august 1914, douglas haig served as a deputy to john french who had become commander-in-chief of the british expeditionary force. Still a cavalry man at heart, David lloyd george, prime minister of a coalition government from december 1916, had questioned the point of launching another costly offensive at passchendaele but haig had got the backing of the conservatives within the coalition and so got his way. Jan 17, 2014. The result was an under-resourced attack in an unfavourable location of little to no strategic value.
  • Was Douglas Haig Really “The Butcher of the Somme”? | History Hit


    . Haigs reticence certainly didnt help his own cause prone to long silences and often coming across as callous. Haig helped manoeuvre the mood-swinging french out of power and was appointed by prime minister herbert asquith as frenchs replacement in december 1915. Aeroplanes and tanks are only accessories to the men and the horse, and i feel sure that as time goes on you will find just as much use for the horsethe well-bred horseas you have ever done in the past. It was clear that victory on the western front was nowhere in sight and planners feared that german industry would not be able to keep up with demand.

    Margaret macmillan talks to her nephew dan about the road to 1914. Yet the very nature of warfare during 1914-1918 meant that offense was no match against deeply entrenched defence the weapons of defence during the first world war were much superior to the weapons of offense. The battle of the somme took place over a front stretching 15 miles. At the outbreak of the first world war, in august 1914, douglas haig served as a deputy to john french who had become commander-in-chief of the british expeditionary force. Douglas haig, britains first world war commander-in-chief from december 1915 to the end of the war, is remembered as the archetypal donkey leading lions to their death by the thousands.

    The length of the front meant commanders needed to be a further away to get a complete picture of what was happening. It is one of the criticisms levelled at haig that he was adverse to new technology. Still a cavalry man at heart, he believed the machine gun to be a much over rated weapon. British soldiers transport a wounded colleague on a wheeled stretcher during the battle of the somme. Haig was not alone generals on all sides puzzled over this uncomfortable truth. However, communications technology was not yet up to the task of keeping commanders updated about the rapidly changing situation at the front. In an interview to the bbc in june 2006, the eve of the 90th anniversary of the first day of the somme, he said, he was not a brutish man, he was a very kind, wonderful man and by god, i miss him i believe it has now turned full circle and people appreciate his contribution. Asked by kitcheners superiors in london to report back in confidence on his commander, haig did so with relish, taking delight in criticising the unsuspecting kitchener. D-day how many men were involved in the invasion of normandy and how many casualties were there? You agree to send your info to history hit who agrees to use it according to their history hit brings you the stories that shaped the world through live events, an award winning podcast network and our new online only history channel. A presbyterian and firmly believing that god was on his side and therefore his decisions had to be right, haig insisted on full frontal attacks, convinced that victory would come by military might alone.

    Jun 26, 2018 ... The negative reputation of Field Marshal Douglas Haig, the commander of British forces on the Western Front during World War One, rests to a ...

    Was Field-Marshal Haig a hero or dunderhead? - Telegraph

    Dec 29, 2007 ... Douglas Haig despised politicians and journalists. Allan Massie ... He was remembered and reviled as a "butcher", "a donkey", "a dunderhead".
  • Online Help With Essay Writing
  • Persuasive Essay Writer
  • Cheap Custom Essay Papers
  • Psychology Thesis Topics
  • Thesis Data Analysis
  • Down These Mean Streets Essay
  • Downfall Of Roman Empire Essay
  • Dr Essay Guillotin Kindly Life Other Science
  • Dr Hessayon Gardening Books
  • Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Essay Contest
  • Theory Of Constraints Master Thesis

    But at wars end, haig was hailed as a hero, and his death saw much public grief, especially in his hometown of edinburgh, and london, where up to a million people turned out to pay their respects. But is the blame justified? The offensive on the somme was initially conceived as part of a wider strategy to wear down the german army by attacking it on all fronts in 1916. D-day how many men were involved in the invasion of normandy and how many casualties were there? You agree to send your info to history hit who agrees to use it according to their history hit brings you the stories that shaped the world through live events, an award winning podcast network and our new online only history channel Buy now Douglas Haig Butcher Or Hero Essay

    Thesis On Knowledge Workers

    But it saddens me my three sisters have not survived to see it. Like the british army at large, the artillery was on a steep learning curve. If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. They discuss the role that masculine insecurity played in the build up to the war and also examine the construct of and myths surrounding nationalistic feeling in the pre-war years. It may have looked like a victory for the allies but the reality was quite different, as subsequent operations against the line in 1917 would show.

    On , douglas haig died from a heart attack brought on, according to his widow, by the strain of wartime command. The scale of the allied offensive on the somme had nevertheless come as a shock to the germans Douglas Haig Butcher Or Hero Essay Buy now

    Thesis On Educational Planning And

    The negative reputation of field marshal douglas haig, the commander of british forces on the western front during world war one, rests to a large degree on his performance at the somme. Designed by sculptor, alfred frank hardiman, and eight years in the making, it won many plaudits and prizes but unfortunately, the stance of the horse is that of one in the process of urinating. Haig has often been criticized of being profligate of mens lives, while many defend him stating that haig had no other alternative. This rapid expansion in scale caused major structural challenges for haig, whose staff had no experience of commanding such large forces. Strictly necessary cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings Buy Douglas Haig Butcher Or Hero Essay at a discount

    Write A Thesis Sentence

    Like the british army at large, the artillery was on a steep learning curve. In 1914, britain went to war with a small professional army. He championed the rights of ex-servicemen and refused all state honours until the government improved their pensions, which duly came in august 1919. But attrition swallowed up allied manpower and material just as quickly as it did the germans. Asked by kitcheners superiors in london to report back in confidence on his commander, haig did so with relish, taking delight in criticising the unsuspecting kitchener.

    The negative reputation of field marshal douglas haig, the commander of british forces on the western front during world war one, rests to a large degree on his performance at the somme Buy Online Douglas Haig Butcher Or Hero Essay

    Write Cause Effect Essay Thesis

    But haig was often under pressure of his french allies to act, bringing forward, for example, the somme offensive by six weeks to help take the pressure off the french at the long slug that was the battle of verdun. At the outbreak of the first world war, in august 1914, douglas haig served as a deputy to john french who had become commander-in-chief of the british expeditionary force. By october, poor weather and continuous artillery bombardment had created a hellish environment for both the allies and the germans. Historian, basil henry liddell hart, who fought during the war, described haig as not merely immoral but criminal. Indeed, the bloodshed of the summer of 1916 has more or less been roundly laid at his door Buy Douglas Haig Butcher Or Hero Essay Online at a discount

    The Origins And Interpretation Of The

    The offensive ultimately led to victory and the surrender of the germans on 11 november. This rapid expansion in scale caused major structural challenges for haig, whose staff had no experience of commanding such large forces. The length of the front meant commanders needed to be a further away to get a complete picture of what was happening. British soldiers transport a wounded colleague on a wheeled stretcher during the battle of the somme. Haigs tenure as c-in-c saw the horrendous losses at the battle of the somme (july-november 1916) and the third battle of ypres, otherwise known as passchendaele, (july-november 1917), for which haig earned the sobriquet the butcher.

    Almost a decade after the war, haig still believed in the use of cavalry i believe that the value of the horse and the opportunity for the horse in the future are likely to be as great as ever Douglas Haig Butcher Or Hero Essay For Sale

    Thesis Disseration

    Still a cavalry man at heart, he believed the machine gun to be a much over rated weapon. Despite having a personal rapport with the king, george v, haig never enjoyed the confidence of lloyd george, who was openly critical of haigs cavalier attitude with his mens lives. It was clear that victory on the western front was nowhere in sight and planners feared that german industry would not be able to keep up with demand. Yet haig prolonged this hell for no real strategic or tactical purpose. Strictly necessary cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

    Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful For Sale Douglas Haig Butcher Or Hero Essay

    Thesis Supervisor Thank You

    Haigs only son, dawyck haig, who was imprisoned in colditz during the second world war and who died in 2009, was a staunch defender of his father. Haigs reticence certainly didnt help his own cause prone to long silences and often coming across as callous. In 1898, he joined the forces of lord kitchener in the sudan. Not only were the armies bigger, but so were the fronts. Of those that did explode, too many were shrapnel shells rather than high explosive, which made little impression on barbed wire and reinforced dug outs.

    Haigs tenure as c-in-c saw the horrendous losses at the battle of the somme (july-november 1916) and the third battle of ypres, otherwise known as passchendaele, (july-november 1917), for which haig earned the sobriquet the butcher Sale Douglas Haig Butcher Or Hero Essay

    MENU

    Home

    Writing

    Research

    Rewiew

    Case study

    Presentation

    Coursework

    Biographies

    Critical

    Paper

    Dissertation

    Thesis About Patience

    Thesis Paper On Shakespeare

    Thesis Statement About Love And Hate

    Thesis Hook Header Aweber

    Thesis On Linux Operating System

    Thesis Theme Change Home Page

    Thesis Statement On Love And Relationships

    Thesis Theory Chapter

    Atlantis Rediscovered

    Thesis Sa Filipino 2 Halimbawa

    Thesis Disseration

    Thesis On Real Estate Market

    Thesis On Teaching English Language Through

    Thesis Projects In Science &Amp

    Thesis On Drainage Problems

    Research Paper
    sitemap

    SPONSOR